Changing minds: How can insurers make a difference on the mental health journey?

Loading player...
Sinenhlanhla Sithomo - Head of Insurance Business: Investec Life talks about A December 2021 report by the Chief Risk Officer’s (CRO) Forum shows that over the past decade there has been a significant shift in insurance claims from physical to mental health with ailments such as burnout, anxiety, and depression overtaking musculoskeletal impairments and neurological diseases. With the latest data from the SA College of Applied Psychology indicating that only 27% of severe mental illnesses in the country are treated,  Sithomo says undiagnosed mental health conditions could be a hidden crisis facing the insurance industry.

 

“As an insurer your biggest risk isn’t actually the people who are disclosing their mental health issues, it’s the people who aren’t aware of their condition and aren’t being treated,” says Sithomo. “Once your mental health claims start ticking up above your musculoskeletal claims your amber flags are no longer amber, they are red flags at that point.”

 

One challenge for insurers is that developing objective diagnostic measurement tools for mental health conditions is not as cut-and-dried as doing so for medical conditions such as cancer or heart disease. When assessing mental health risk underwriters have to rely on questionnaires, which have traditionally given insufficient consideration to clients’ social support structures, often resulting in adverse underwriting outcomes for applicants that should have been deemed low risk.

 

“Clients who proactively seek care and disclose a mental health condition also tend to receive harsher underwriting outcomes compared to those who do not seek care and remain undiagnosed,” says Sithomo. “This is why it’s critical that we begin to transform our underwriting protocols and incorporate as many of the biopsychosocial factors in risk assessment for clients with mental health conditions.”

 

Interestingly, Sithomo says the catalyst for placing greater emphasis on mental health conditions has not been the economic stresses that have surfaced in the wake of Covid-19. In fact, he says Investec Life first began looking at mental health in 2018 when advisers began reporting increased mental health complaints from young doctors.

 

Since then, the insurer has been looking at ways to better assess the mental health of its fairly well-off client base with Sithomo saying rising income protection claims attributed to mental health are regarded as the “first amber flag” that the client population is under stress.

 

A sustained increase in these claims is typically followed by a spike in long-term disability lump sum claims from mental health related issues. Unfortunately, these claims are often followed by increased death claims from suicide.

 

While suicide typically has a two-year exclusion for claims, once that time period has passed insurers are liable to pay out meaning it is in both their and their clients interest that mental health interventions take place earlier rather than later. Improving the identification of mental health risks during the underwriting process is one way to do this but stigma can be a problem, particularly among male clients.

 

“As life insurers, we can contribute towards the destigmatisation of mental health by making changes in the way we underwrite these conditions,” says Sithomo. “Greater awareness will go a long way towards destigmatising mental health as people begin to better understand their own mental health status and become open to disclosing the potential challenges they encounter when they seek out treatment. This shift is certainly in the interest of the life insurance industry.”
8 Dec 2022 1PM English South Africa Business News · Investing

Other recent episodes

South Africa's Car Buyers Defy Economic Pressure

Despite higher interest rates, rising fuel prices and growing living costs, South Africa's vehicle market continues to show remarkable resilience. Thanda Sithole, Senior Economist at FNB and WesBank, unpacks what strong vehicle sales reveal about consumer confidence, how buyers are adapting to affordability pressures, the rise of new-energy vehicles, and…
12 Nov 12PM 13 min

The Economics of Diabetes

Ahead of World Diabetes Day, Sara Norcross, VP and General Manager of Novo Nordisk South Africa, joins Kaya Biz to discuss the growing burden of diabetes and its impact beyond healthcare. From workplace productivity and economic growth to treatment access and prevention, the conversation explores why diabetes should be viewed…
12 Nov 12PM 20 min

Protecting Yourself in the Age of Digital Scams

Online scams are becoming more sophisticated and increasingly difficult to detect. Sylvia Musalagani, Head of Safety Policy for Europe, the Middle East and Africa at Meta, discusses the growing threat of digital fraud, Meta's anti-scam initiatives, and how partnerships with local institutions are helping consumers identify and avoid online scams…
12 Nov 11AM 10 min

South Africa's Capital Puzzle

South Africa has no shortage of capital, yet economic growth remains elusive. Jurie Strydom, CEO of Old Mutual, joins Kaya Biz to unpack why the challenge may not be attracting investment, but deploying existing capital into productive sectors of the economy. The conversation explores investor confidence, policy certainty, infrastructure constraints…
12 Nov 11AM 7 min

Reading South Africa's Economic Pulse

South Africa's economic activity weakened again in October, but there are emerging signs that pressure on households and businesses may begin to ease. Independent economist Elize Kruger unpacks the latest PayInc Economic Index, the fuel price outlook, consumer behaviour, business confidence and the key economic trends to watch heading into…
11 Nov 12PM 10 min